Feature Request: Edit mouse movements post-recording

  • 15
  • Idea
  • Updated 1 month ago
  • Implemented
I prepare professional software training videos, and oftentimes would like to edit the mouse movements after recording.

This can happen because I make a cut, or because I need to refilm part of the screencast, and don't get my mouse right where it needs to be for a seamless transition. Or sometimes there will be a distracting mouse movement I would like to refilm, even though everything else is perfect.

I know there are some workarounds, but they are very time consuming and difficult to implement.

There are numerous other posts about this on the forum (such as here), but the ones I found that are "Ideas" are already locked, so I thought I would repost this now that TechSmith is asking for new feature ideas. Thanks!
Photo of fdr

fdr

  • 15 Posts
  • 5 Reply Likes

Posted 4 years ago

  • 15
Photo of Jack Fruh

Jack Fruh, Champion

  • 583 Posts
  • 204 Reply Likes
Great suggestion. The only work around I can think of is to set your desktop to a green background, then remove the background and overlay the video - which would be a lot of work.
Photo of training

training

  • 119 Posts
  • 41 Reply Likes
I had that problem and decided not to use my mouse as I recorded. I added the arrows and highlights as I edited. They were bolder, so easier to see, and much easier to place and time with the audio.
Photo of davemillman

davemillman

  • 718 Posts
  • 253 Reply Likes
This is a real problem, which Camtasia cannot completely solve for us. Here are the techniques I use: 
  1. When I know that mouse movement will be a critical part of the video, I record that segment of the video three times or more, then choose the best one in edit.
  2. In edit, it's easier to speed up a slow mouse movement than to slow down a fast mouse movement.
  3. Like Training suggested in the previous comment, frequently it is easier and more effective to move the mouse off the screen, then add annotations or highlights later.
  4. It's time consuming, but you can use photoshop to create a mouse pointer as a graphic, then animate that moving around the screen. This is a great solution when you have a recording which is otherwise perfect, but is missing a crucial mouse movement. It can work surprisingly well. I've gotten in the habit of starting critical captures with the mouse static on a blank part of the screen, so I can extract a perfectly matched mouse pointer if necessary.
Photo of Robert R.

Robert R., Online Community Admin

  • 1682 Posts
  • 557 Reply Likes
Hi and thanks for submitting your idea/feature request!

As outlined in our New Community Processes post, feature requests are open to voting up through the first, where we will then tally the votes and present the findings to our product teams. To ensure we have the most accurate data, on the 1st of the month we will be locking the threads that were listed in the Feature Request Round-up that was posted on the 15th. Once we have reviewed the submitted feature requests, our product team(s) may respond to the request, and if that is the case then that thread will then be unlocked for further discussion.

In the event that your idea is not selected for a response feel free to resubmit the idea and share it with your colleagues to garner as much exposure as possible!

Thank you again for your idea and we look forward to hearing more from you!

-Robert
Photo of Dan

Dan, Product Manager - Audiate

  • 15 Posts
  • 23 Reply Likes
Official Response
Hi there, 

I definitely understand the frustration of having done lots of editing and getting your content exactly how you want it, only to have a jumpy cursor ruin the whole video. I myself have had to come up with quite a few workarounds for the cursor movement in order to make my videos look professional.

While I can't make any promises, I can assure you that issues like this are going to be looked at and evaluated with the goal of making sure you can make professional looking content without hours of workarounds.

We spent a long time getting Camtasia to parity across platform and making sure it was a platform we could build on in the future. Now we're ready to go full steam ahead and focus on solving problems like these!
Photo of cparks

cparks

  • 1 Post
  • 1 Reply Like
I can't believe you don't have this feature... even the low cost demo software can do this. Not sure if i will buy.  Don't want to spend my time doing dubs till I get the courser movement proper.
Photo of oscar

oscar

  • 6 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
Can anyone from TechSmith Support tell something about the status of this feature request? Would be so nice to be able to edit mouse movements / smoothen movements in post-recording, still waiting and praying... Thanx in advance!
Photo of Nilou Derakhshan

Nilou Derakhshan

  • 1 Post
  • 0 Reply Likes
is there any update on this feature? Seems like the issue's been resolved only for Windows users. Is the feature will be available for Mac users too? Thank you!
Photo of Brooks

Brooks, Camtasia Technical Product Manager

  • 306 Posts
  • 264 Reply Likes
Camtasia 2019 added a new feature called Cursor Smoothing that is available on both platforms. I'd suggest downloading the trial and giving it a whirl.

What does it do? In short, cursor smoothing tries to detect the "important" locations on the screen where you've moved your mouse, and transitions between these locations as seamlessly as possible.

How are "important" locations decided? There are two factors we take into consideration:

  • Clicks: These tend to be the most important parts of mouse movement, so we use them as a basis for smoothing. In other words, at its most basic level, cursor smoothing will simply make the cursor move smoothly from one click location to the next click location.
  • Pauses: During testing, we found that it was very useful to also try and detect the places where the cursor has simply stopped moving. For example, if you've clicked on a text field, then moved the cursor away so it doesn't block the field while you're typing, we try to detect that and account for it. Note that cursor pauses can be toggled off, but are turned on by default.
What are my options?

There are (currently) four ways that cursor smoothing can be adjusted. These can be changed in the Cursor Smoothing properties panel:

  • Duration: This is the intended duration of each cursor movement, which is 1 second by default. For example, if you've clicked something at 1 second, and then clicked something else at 10 seconds, the mouse cursor will stay at the first click location until 9 seconds, and will then take 1 second to move smoothly from the first click location to the second click location.
  • Delay: In our testing, we found that it looks strangely robotic when the mouse cursor moves to a click location and stops moving the moment the click happens. It especially looks robotic when the mouse immediately moves away the moment the click ends. To make it look more "human", we added a slight delay before and after each click, which is 0.25 seconds by default. This means the mouse will move to the click location, hover for 0.25 seconds before the click, and then hover an additional 0.25 seconds after the click before moving again.
  • Easing: When easing is turned on (which is the default state), the cursor will move slowly at first, building up to full speed halfway through the movement, then slow down at the end of the movement. When easing is turned off, the cursor will move at a constant speed throughout the whole movement. We added this option to hopefully emulate a natural cursor movement, and appear less robotic.
  • Detect Cursor Pauses: When this option is turned on (which is the default state), we detect when the cursor has not moved more than 30 pixels for longer than 0.8 seconds, and include those locations in addition to clicks. This happens most often when trying to point something out with the mouse cursor, or simply trying to move the cursor out of the way.

Brooks
Camtasia Technical Product Manager
Mobile Technical Product Manager
TechSmith
Photo of Reinhard Holzner

Reinhard Holzner

  • 2 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
The mouse smoothing is actually an improvement - but it does not help, we urgently need the capability to really EDIT the mouse path. All our videos look semi professional because mouseover effects do not match the smoothed cursor path anymore etc. - it is nearly impossible to fix this, and a LOT of work. If I knew this in advance I would not have purchased Camtasia but used another tool.
Photo of dave.clootie

dave.clootie

  • 3 Posts
  • 2 Reply Likes
Reading this gives impression that the original feature request has been implemented - which is wrong.

Can someone official details if there are plans to give Camtasia 2020 the ability to "re-record mouse" movements over a selection of segments in time line.

The above is the only way to fix either missing mouse movement which may also included clicks.  or  Wherfe mouse movement is critical being able to record without mouse as editing will destroy any mouse flow, but have ability once video is edited at end to add mouse movement.

Other competing packages have this feature, seems a shame Camtasia is lacking it.
Photo of paulwilliamengle

paulwilliamengle

  • 422 Posts
  • 156 Reply Likes
1) I wholly support this feature request. Getting mouse movement exactly how I want it is a big time sink.

2) I'm curious - what other software applications offer this functionality? 
Photo of dave.clootie

dave.clootie

  • 3 Posts
  • 2 Reply Likes
BB Flashback Pro - offers re-recording of mouse movements
Photo of kayakman

kayakman, Champion

  • 8061 Posts
  • 2784 Reply Likes
my go-to solution for adding mouse movements after-the-fact is to capture the mouse moving as needed, over a full-screened detached canvas; that capture is added on a higher track in the target project, and remove a color applied to the mouse capture clip to make its background transparent [black canvas seems to work well here], I also increase cursor size to 500%, and add cursor effects where appropriate

here is a short example where the cursor and narration was added/animated in a blank canvas, then superposed over an image as a clip on track 2 ...

Example - Video Where Mouse Movements Added After The Fact 2020-05-29
https://www.screencast.com/t/RA5i0Dyl

Photo of Reinhard Holzner

Reinhard Holzner

  • 2 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
Lol. Its incredible which workarounds people develop because TechSmith isnt listening. I loved the tool, but missing mouse path editing was so annoying that I am not using it anymore.

PS: no, the mouse path smoothing and other stuff supplied is NOT helping.
(Edited)